Suppose $1\in D^+$. If you keep adding $1$ to itself $p-1$ times, you arrive at $-1\in D^+$ as well. But by trichotomy, both $1$ and $-1$ cannot be in $D^+$ at the same time.
Suppose $1\in D^+$. If you keep adding $1$ to itself $p-1$ times, you arrive at $-1\in D^+$ as well. But by trichotomy, both $1$ and $-1$ cannot be in $D^+$ at the same time.