If you want to charge in proportion to usage, then charge Jim $5/(5+2) = 5/7$ of the leftover plywood, and Joe $2/7$ of the leftover. That means Jim is charged for about $2.14$ sq ft of the plywood and Joe for the rest.
If you want to charge in proportion to usage, then charge Jim $5/(5+2) = 5/7$ of the leftover plywood, and Joe $2/7$ of the leftover. That means Jim is charged for about $2.14$ sq ft of the plywood and Joe for the rest.