You need to be precise about what you mean by a year, but in practise all alternatives will give you 1 as the correct answer.
Either you define a year so that it has constant length, for example 365.24 days, and then you observe that the difference between the two dates differs from 3 years with less than a day. This is the approach astronomers would take in their work.
Or you define a year so that it always has a whole number of days, like in the Julian or the Gregorian calendar. Then a year will not have constant length, which is messy when you work with astronomy, but is OK for most everyday purposes. Also in that case you get the same answer of 3 years, or Alternative 1.