Well clearly you want to find $f_n\in I$ with $||f_n-f||_1\to0$ but $f\
otin I$. A hint regarding one way to construct such a sequence: Say $f\in L^1$ and $g(t)=e^{ict}f(t)$. How are $\hat f$ and $\hat g$ related?
Ok, a solution, since the OP has given up. We know that if $\psi\in C^2_c$ then there exists $f\in L^1$ with $\psi=\hat f$. So we can choose $f\in L^1$ such that $\hat f(\xi)=0$ for all $\xi<0$ while $\hat f(\xi)>0$ for all $\xi\in(0,1)$. Let $f_n(x)=e^{ix/n}f(x)$. Then $f_n\in I$, $||f-f_n||_1\to0$ and $f\
otin I$.