Let $$s\mapsto z(s)\qquad(0\leq s\leq L)$$ be the counterclockwise representation of the crust with respect to arc length. Hold a knive over the sandwich connecting the points $z(0)$ and $z(L/2)$, and assume that the area to the right of the knive is more than half of the sandwich. Now turn the knive slowly counterclockwise so that at all times it points from $z(s)$ to $z(s+L/2)$. When we arrive at $s=L/2$ we will have less than half of the sandwich to the right of the knive. By the intermediate value theorem there has to be a position $\sigma\in\ ]0,L/2[\ $ of the knive for which the area of the sandwich is exactly halved.